The very first thing I believed after I awoke Wednesday morning was that there’s now an SNL Curse. Any feminine U.S. presidential candidate — even one who seems to be cruising to the White Home — will finally lose the election if she seems on Saturday Evening Stay. First Hillary Clinton in 2016 and now Kamala Harris in 2024.
I’m curious how music will react to the brand new Trump administration. Tradition is at all times simply downstream from what’s taking place in society. Traditionally, issues shift relying on whether or not the White Home (and 10 Downing Road, for that matter) is occupied by a right- or left-wing administration. This correlation between politics and music suits in properly with my concept of the 13-year pop vs. rock cycle.
When Dwight Eisenhower, a Republican, took over for 2 phrases within the Nineteen Fifties, American music grew to become much more rebellious, manifesting, at the least partly within the delivery and development of rock ‘n’ roll. And let’s not neglect in regards to the folks motion with its many left-leaning artists discovering buy with progressives.
The following two phrases — John F. Kennedy’s shortened presidency adopted by Lyndon B. Johnson — have been Democrat. Large social change ensued, due to the calls for of the boomers, the Vietnam Conflict, the civil rights motion and the struggle for ladies’s rights. It was a chaotic time. Boomers, emboldened by the promise of progress and offended about Vietnam, started to make music that mirrored their desires, wants, goals and fears.
By the point Republican Richard Nixon took over in 1968, rock had grown very loud, and in some instances, very offended. It was throughout his first time period that metallic (Led Zeppelin, Deep Purple, Steppenwolf et al) was born, and storage rock, a precursor to punk, started to unfold (assume Stooges, MC5, and The New York Dolls). It was additionally a golden period of protest music in rock.
When Nixon resigned in shame in 1974, his Republican successor tried to maintain the Republican lights on however finally misplaced to Democrat Jimmy Carter — however not earlier than punk sprouted in NYC (Ramones, Speaking Heads, Blondie) after which unfold to London (Intercourse Pistols, The Conflict). In some ways, punk was a response to the right-wing methods of presidency since 1968. It burned very popular and really vivid with righteous anger.
The Carter years had their points, however for essentially the most half, folks felt ok after the Watergate nightmare to get out and social gathering. Disco exploded. New Wave was enjoyable and quirky. Radio was dominated by feel-good pop and rock.
Get every day Nationwide information
Get the day’s high information, political, financial, and present affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox as soon as a day.
That every one ended with the Reagan and Thatcher years as right-leaning governments took workplace on either side of the Atlantic together with a recession that pushed rates of interest past 20 per cent. Really feel-good music started to ebb whereas new arduous and heavy genres — hardcore punk, goth, industrial, hair-and-spandex bands and crushing ranges of metallic — took root and started to unfold. And whereas pop did have a second within the latter half of the ’80s, it might not final.
The ’90s started with one other yr of Republican and conservative rule and younger folks have been fed up. There was a brutal recession, the primary Gulf Conflict, and a way among the many new gen Xers that they have been by no means going to realize the usual of residing loved by their dad and mom. Rock exploded in recognition on either side of the Atlantic as a result of it was the style (together with a fast-growing hip-hop scene) finest for expressing anger, worry and a want for change. Therefore grunge, extra punk, industrial, Britpop and so forth.
This, after all, didn’t final. With Democrat Invoice Clinton taking workplace in 1992, the deeply unpopular Margaret Thatcher out of workplace, and a quickly enhancing economic system, rock’s rock-the-boat method fell out of favour. Pop — woman singers and boy bands, particularly — dominated for a number of years.
Then got here 9/11, one of the traumatic occasions we’ve ever seen. Invasions and wars adopted underneath Republican George W. Bush. Joyful, dancey music as soon as once more appeared inappropriate given the state of the world, and late gen Xers and early millennials gravitated to music that was extra critical and darkish. We ended up with the indie rock revival, emo, extra punk and a resurgence in bands like U2, Inexperienced Day, 9 Inch Nails, Foo Fighters and Purple Sizzling Chili Peppers.
To date, so good. However then this decades-long correlation between the recognition of rock music and right-wing administrations begins to disintegrate.
You’d have thought that the monetary disaster of 2008 and its aftermath would have resulted in offended music taking on the mainstream. It didn’t. The 2 phrases of Barack Obama had little considerable impact on the general trajectory of rock and pop. In truth, issues began falling aside.
Why? Expertise.
When Donald Trump was first elected in 2016, I boldly predicted that rock would as soon as once more rise as a bulwark to a right-leaning America. We’d all quickly be awash in contemporary new metallic bands, loads of punk, and darkish beat-heavy bands. Elder millennials and livid gen Zers would produce loads of heavy rock and intense hip-hop.
Nope. It didn’t occur. As an alternative, in style music continued to splinter into not simply a whole lot of genres however 1000’s. Trump did Trump and the conservatives stumbled via the 2010s with out there being any considerable widespread mainstream musical response or motion.
COVID-19? You’d assume that each one the worry and points surrounding the pandemic may need introduced us collectively when it got here to being on the identical web page with music. Nope.
Streaming has turn into utterly entrenched in our music consumption habits. Smartphones permit rapid free entry to tens and tens of tens of millions of songs. Not like the pre-internet, pre-streaming period, there isn’t any centre to music, no consensus about what we must be listening to if we need to belong. We’re all our personal music administrators, free to customise our music consumption in no matter method we wish utilizing the complete library of recorded music.
MuchMusic and MTV not set tendencies with music movies and deserted them altogether. Music magazines have disappeared. Social media breeds one-hit wonders. Rock radio has struggled to seek out new superstars. Oh, there have been just a few, however nowhere close to the numbers we noticed again within the ’90s and early 2000s. Not even shut.
The 2024 U.S. presidential election uncovered extraordinarily deep and sophisticated divisions in American society. Now that the nation might be ruled by the furthest right-leaning administration within the nation’s historical past, how will music reply? Will points like abortion and ladies’s well being care, entry to contraception, tax cuts for the wealthy, the affect of billionaires on nationwide and worldwide coverage, Russia, Ukraine, China, Taiwan, Mission 2025, and all the remainder of it change the tone and tenor of in style music?
Perhaps. The course of music has at all times been pushed by youth. Certain, lots of people might be offended, however let’s see if they’ll get collectively to indicate it. A nation — the world — turns its lonely eyes to you.
